Exedor's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[It's The Puppet Show!]

Don't submit Youtube videos! If you have the file, submit it. Otherwise, don't.

StringAnime responds:

Embedded Links in a SWF is the correct way to present Large High Quality Movies on Newgrounds. It's New to CS5 AS 3.0. Read the AUTHOR'S COMMENTS at the Top under the Movie. Your review violates the rules of a proper review on Newgrounds. READ the NEWGROUNDS RULES.
Get with the Times and stop being a snob.

[Strawberry's Break #3]

How can I send you a PM when you disabled them??? :'(

MistyE responds:

wait I have PMs disabled? sorry

[Mommy!]

Put it in the Art Portal.

I know this is what you were going for; having just a pic set to music, but it doesn't really add anything to it. Well, not enough to be in the animation side. The Flash Portal is for animations, and this is still just a picture and nothing more. It would do well in the Art Portal, though. You've got some good stuff there.

BTW, it didn't quite look enough like Obama. ;)

Michael1957 responds:

Thanks. I'll have to work on my Obama.

[DeadField]

Awesome!

Complete it out with a story. Or a fight scene. That seems to be what it was building to.

People underestimate the creative ideas that can come from listening to a piece of music. I've got several ideas for great animations, most of which are built around a piece of music that I had heard somewhere. I just don't have flash to create them yet.

Awesome job here. :)

LessThanNormal responds:

In the back ofour minds we have comipled a rough story along with (what might eventually become) a fight scene that generally explains what has happened or what will happen. And yes music can create many many things, where as if might be a story or animation it does have that effect on people. We all have ideas and I hope that you'll be able to show some of yours once you finally get Flash. Thanks again for the comment.

[VG Cats Animated 6]

Ouch!

After I left the good review yesterday on the Christmas episode, you had me scared on this one. You saved it after the first ending though. That was some muddy territory you were walking thru there. :\

After the first end, the pause before the 2nd part starts is long enough that some people may shut it off, thinking that's all there is, and give a lower score. The first part was rough, but the 2nd part pulled it out. If people watch the whole thing, you should be ok. If they shut it off when they see the first credits, your score may suffer. :\

:)

MikeandTreyVideo responds:

Yeah, I weighed the risk of having something like that in the middle when trying to entertain young teens. It was a lot less work than animating the second comic strip that originally ties these other two together.

[VG Cats Christmas Special]

I think your stuff is awesome.

Especially this one.

Ignore the haters.

Anyway, keep up the good work! :D

MikeandTreyVideo responds:

thanks.

he's just a weak troll and I was foolish enough to feed him for a bit.

[1 Take 1 Loop]

If only everyone submitted good stuff like this!

Well done on an intelligent animation.

Carr77 responds:

Thanks! B^)