Exedor's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[robotman [Demo]]

Don't submit tests.

This wasn't bad. Feel free to continue with your project.

But don't submit tests. This isn't Testgrounds. This is one enemy, 1 level, 1 1/2 screens long, with no end and no music. If it passes, what then? We'll be stuck with a pointless fragment of a game floating around here forever.

It's good, but please don't submit tests.

[School Word Search]

The game is ok.

But we need more time.

[lionel messi nightmare]

It's not bad...

But you should be able to survive hitting at least one obstacle without dying! :\

[Epic Defense Battles]

The game seems ok...

But the resetting of the progress ruins it.

The guys don't go after who they need to go after. I'll drop a guy behind someone I need taken out, and they'll pass him up to go after other people. If I can't destroy who I need to destroy, it's bad. If I lose and then lose all my progress, then that's no fun. Games that aren't fun don't get played.

coffingames responds:

Thanks for the feedback. Hmm, maybe you are right, resetting of the progress could have been there only in hard and insane modes and not in normal mode. Unit AI, most people have liked, some have complained (with the analytics data gathered from game and feedback from a lot of different people). But I believe its really hard to make the AI that everyone likes. I will take care of things with broad perspective (like this) to handle them with extra care.

[Santa Chops]

It looks good. It sounds good.

But it's horrible to play. There aren't nearly enough houses to support long term play. The presents don't give enough "life" for you to last more than a few houses. You can leave the first house full, but by the time you get to the second house, you're at less than 25% life. Despite getting 6 presents into the second house, I still had only about 1/3 life, which isn't enough to make it to house 3. If you miss a chimney, you're screwed. The highest I ever got was house 4, but not as far as it's chimney. There were many times I couldn't get to house 3 at all. If you miss house 1, you'll never make it to house 2.

it looks good, but it's no fun at all to play.

mymoog responds:

Thanks for the comments. I've increased the amount of 'life' you get from dropping presents :)

[Charrue]

This wasn't bad. :)

Some music would help. And high scores would be nice too.

[Baby Baby Baby]

This game is nasty!

And not just cuz it has Beiber in it. It was low class until the babies started having cords. Then it became tasteless and nasty. WTF!

[Reactance]

What an awesome game!

The music is awesome and fits it well! I can waste a lot of my time on this and enjoy doing it.
:)

[Cubz]

This is bloody awful!

There are no instructions.
There's no music.
No sounds.
No replay button.
The background ...hurts.

You may want to change a few things before you submit another. This needs a lot of help. :\

[Epic Fantasy: City Tycoon]

"this game is ''unfinished.'' Please be nice"

Dood. If you submit half a game, you're going to get comments that are "half-happy."

But this isn't even half a game!
It's 1 screen.
He's got no life in his hearts.
The enemies leave before you can get to them.
There's no menu, start screen, end screen, or any way to die.

Why would you submit something like this? It's nowhere near being playable, much less being completed. I gave you 1 star because it looks good. Until you try to do anything.

Please don't submit unfinished things. Especially when they don't do anything. It says right on the submit page: "Your movie must not be a pointless "demo" or "preview" without any redeeming qualities."

Please pay attention to the Newgrounds rules. And if you want good reviews, submit finished games that are good. :)