Exedor's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[-NemesiS-]

This was kinda good.

It was way too slow. "Who am I?" Walking... Sitting... Taking hat off... Sitting again... Candle... Taking hat off again... blah...blah...on and on. The video quality was good. The subject might have been interesting, but the pace was way too slow.

Also, it wasn't animated. Please keep the videos on youtube. Newgrounds was started as an outlet for people to post their animations. There's been too much video stuff submitted, when it's intended to be a flash site.

You've got animations on here. Please make more. But keep the videos on youtube.

GAMECUBICLE responds:

There are also stopmotion films here on newgrounds, which we all know and love. Which is also not flash.

This movie was shot greenscreen and everything is edited in. Making the entire movie about 90% digital footage and animation, so I don't see a reason why this shouldn't be here.

[Tripod Spider Thing]

This isn't bad, but...

...no, please don't store your tests here. This isn't Testgrounds. This animation was not bad. I liked it. The problem is that when people see parts and bits of flashes on here, then they want to submit their own parts and bits. If everyone put as much work into them as you did in this one, that might not be so bad. If they did as well as you did with this, it might not be so bad. But they don't, and we've got a lot of crap that get on here that shouldn't be, simply because people aren't sure what's supposed to pass anymore.

I look forward to seeing more for you. You've already shown that you're better than a lot of the noobies that show up here. Keep trying, and don't get discouraged if this doesn't pass. Tests aren't supposed to pass, but they do.

I liked it, but it's not enough to stay on here. Yet. :)

[COMET]

I hate it when people vote 5 on just anything...

...when it's flashes like this that are the ones that deserve them. 5/5 10/10

Absolutely awesome!

[Not Late]

Dood....

...but it's Saturday! :O

:)

[BTS 2 Trailer]

Video is for youtube.

Newgrounds is for animation. Now, you've done the Pyroscape games, and they're ok, cuz they're games. Animations and games are what Newgrounds is about. But for full video, please go to youtube.

And be nice to your reviewers. I thought you were ok til I saw you being rude to those below me. Now, not sure. :\ So remember: your reviewers will judge your personality by how you deal with them in your review comments.

Fro responds:

I could explode on you and tell you about 10 ways that you are wrong, but meh, newgrounds has changed. When I submitted these flashes before they won awards and scored into the 4.00 + range. Ignorance is a bliss I suppose.

[Doctor Who 1985 Totl Spjv]

As much as I like Doctor Who...

You have to do more than that. All you did was take the video and run a filter. The NG submit page says: "You may parody existing Flash submissions, but you must use your own artwork and not rip another author's art." So, yeah. You need to do your own work. If you just modify someone else's stuff, it'll get blammed or flagged. :\

:)

HUNT3Rdotme responds:

... Good point ..........

[Roy Santana]

She's got see-thru clothes!

How is this Suitable for Everyone??? Change your rating on this.

[A Shiny Minecraft tale]

Awesome!

This is great. The medals are cool. But there's a glitch. I got all the tools, and all the weapons, and I missed 2 diamonds. It gave me 1 diamond at the end. I tried again and got 2 diamonds, and it gave me 2 diamonds at the end. I had a hard time getting the last diamond, but when I did, it only gave me the middle diamond at the end. :\ Several tries still got the same result, even after reloading.

wynand responds:

=D thank you kind sir. All fixed now, I'm not really a coder by trade haha =D. Thanks

[Squelch Step Album Promo]

The flash portal is for animation.

The audio portal is for audio...stuff. And your's counts as audio stuff.

This is a slideshow that creeps along WAY to slow. It's boring. It's not animated.

Please submit stuff like this to the Audio Portal where it belongs. I don't know that it counts as music, but it counts as audio, so that's where it should be.

:)